First time that I saw you, you got me with a song
You wrote about a girl you said you didn't want
You came across so clever, so confident, complete

I could not believe it when you said you wanted me

I thought it was too good to be true

I was wrong but I was right about you
Nights spent in your arms became days spent in hell
Wondering where you are and if I was fooling myself


We both know you're as fickle as a San Francisco sky
While me I like to plan so as not to freeze or fry

I thought it was too good to be true
But I stopped thinking real soon


And I don't think this is goodbye, but it sure ain't see you soon
It's gonna be a while before I can stand close to you
Because oh god how it hurt when I finally had proof

I don't know what's worse -- to hear a lie or know the truth

I thought it was too good to be true

But I really I wanted it to be you
I thought it was too good to be true
I was wrong but I was right about you